Financial Challenges Faced by Indian Farmers: A Case Study

Agriculture stands as the cornerstone of the Indian economy, influencing not only the livelihoods of millions but also contributing significantly to the nation's overall economic landscape. In the pursuit of understanding the intricate dynamics between agriculture and the economy, our research focused on conducting a comprehensive survey among Indian farmers. The overarching goal was to gain insights into the challenges faced by farmers, the impact of agricultural practices on the economy, and potential avenues for improvement. The survey revealed a multifaceted picture of the agricultural sector, underscoring both its vitality and vulnerability. Respondents highlighted the persistent struggles with unpredictable weather patterns, inadequate access to modern technology, and fluctuations in market prices. Despite these challenges, there emerged a resilient spirit among farmers, with many expressing a commitment to sustainable farming practices. Crucially, the survey shed light on the need for targeted policy interventions to bolster the agricultural sector. Recommendations included enhancing irrigation infrastructure, promoting the adoption of technology-driven farming practices, and establishing stable pricing mechanisms. By bridging the gap between research findings and actionable policy measures, this work aims to contribute to the ongoing dialogue surrounding the pivotal role of agriculture in shaping India's economic future.


Introduction
Agriculture is a major contributor in the Indian Economy, contributing roughly 18% to the GDP, Millions of people are directly dependent on it for survival, therefore protecting the agriculture economy is of utmost importance, Environmental factors play a huge role in the yield of a crop, therefore to prevent damage from natural disasters, techniques have to be used to protect the land and livelihood of the people dependent on it.The agricultural economy of India boasts a rich and varied history, deeply interwoven with the country's cultural and social fabric.Dating back thousands of years, India's agriculture has witnessed the rise and fall of various civilizations and the emergence of diverse farming practices.Ancient texts such as the Rigveda and Arthashastra highlight the significance of agriculture, detailing sophisticated irrigation methods and crop cultivation techniques.Throughout the medieval period, the Mughal Empire played a pivotal role in shaping agricultural practices, introducing new crops and advanced cultivation methods.The British colonial era marked a significant transformation, as land revenue systems were altered, impacting traditional agrarian structures.Post-independence, India witnessed the Green Revolution in the mid-20th century, characterized by the adoption of high-yielding varieties of crops and modern agricultural techniques.Today, the agricultural sector remains a vital component of the Indian economy, supporting millions of livelihoods, while ongoing efforts focus on sustainable practices, technological innovation, and rural development to ensure the sector's resilience and growth.India's agricultural sector has undergone significant developments over the years, shaping the landscape of the country's economy and rural livelihoods.Some key developments include:

Green Revolution (1960s-1970s):
The Green Revolution marked a transformative phase in Indian agriculture, characterized by the adoption of high-yielding varieties of seeds, increased use of fertilizers and pesticides, and advanced irrigation techniques.This period saw a substantial increase in food grain production, particularly in wheat and rice, leading to improved food security and self-sufficiency.

Land Reforms (1950s-1970s):
Post-independence, India implemented land reforms to address issues of land distribution and tenancy.The goal was to reduce landlessness and enhance the economic status of small and marginalized farmers.Land consolidation and tenancy reforms aimed to create more equitable land distribution.

Technology Adoption and Mechanization:
The adoption of modern agricultural technologies, including tractors, combine harvesters, and other machinery, has increased efficiency and productivity in farming.Precision farming practices, such as the use of drones and GPS technology, are gradually becoming more prevalent.

National Agricultural Policy (2000):
The National Agricultural Policy aimed at promoting sustainable agriculture, enhancing productivity, and ensuring the overall welfare of farmers.It emphasized the importance of diversification, organic farming, and agri-infrastructure development.

Organic Farming Movement:
There is a growing interest in organic farming practices in India, with increased awareness of environmental sustainability and health concerns.Various government initiatives and private efforts promote organic farming as a viable and eco-friendly alternative.

National Mission on Sustainable Agriculture (NMSA):
Launched in 2010, NMSA focuses on promoting sustainable agricultural practices, water use efficiency, and soil health management.The mission addresses issues such as climate change resilience and natural resource conservation.

Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY):
PMFBY, launched in 2016, is a crop insurance scheme designed to protect farmers against yield losses due to natural calamities, pests, and diseases.• Email: editor@ijfmr.comIJFMR240111840 Volume 6, Issue 1, January-February 2024 3 The scheme aims to provide financial stability to farmers and encourage risk management.

E-NAM (National Agriculture Market):
The Electronic National Agriculture Market is an online trading platform launched to connect agricultural markets across states and promote transparent price discovery.E-NAM facilitates electronic trading, reducing intermediary costs and improving market access for farmers.

PM-KISAN Scheme:
The Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi Yojana, launched in 2019, provides direct income support to small and marginal farmers.Under this scheme, eligible farmers receive financial assistance directly into their bank accounts.

Rural Development Initiatives:
Various rural development programs focus on creating rural infrastructure, improving irrigation facilities, and providing access to credit and markets for farmers.These initiatives aim to uplift the socio-economic conditions of rural communities and enhance agricultural productivity.
The following are key challenges faced by the Indian farmers: Lack of access to credit and finance: Farmers often have to request financial support from the government to aid in the farming of crops, but due to unforeseen natural disasters, when the crops get destroyed, they are unable to sell anything resulting in debt and they have to wait another year for the next harvesting cycle depending on the severity of damage and type of crop.This results in a lot of financial burden and psychological stress on the farmers resulting in farmer suicides.

Small Land holdings:
Most of the farmers own a small area of land to cultivate crops, this results in not being able to use modern farming technology, therefore they have to stick to old methods of farming and get low yield per unit area.

Water scarcity:
In India, the farming industry is heavily dependent on monsoon rains due to scarcity of available water for farming, this makes the industry quite vulnerable to droughts and other natural disasters.Access to irrigation facilities is a major challenge that need to be addressed.

Degradation of soil fertility:
Excessive use of chemical insecticides and pesticides has led to soil degradation.Now the crop production is low in nutrients.Latest techniques have to be used to limit the use of such chemicals and make the soil fertile again.

Market Volatility and price fluctuations:
Indian farmers have to face market instability, due to this prices are unstable, so they tend to not make as much profit as they would have wanted.This creates a problem because they never fully are able to repay their debts.

Literature Review
Nilabja Ghosh (2004), his research delves into the Indian agriculture's significant reliance on chemical fertilizers that has harmed soil quality, rendering current technology unsustainable.To solve this, a more balanced strategy mixing chemical fertilizers and organic manure is suggested.While there are concerns about potential production and revenue losses, the study focuses on the environmental benefits of such a transformation.Despite increased fertilizer use, historical statistics show that organic manure use has lagged.Quadratic yield functions and household-level statistics confirm the viability of this transition, implying that compensation for impacted households and a dynamic manure market are critical for successful implementation.[1] K. Ravi Shankar and Pochaiah Maraty (2009), their research offers a crucial perspective on the various elements contributing to farmers' debt and hardship in India.Farmers' reliance on capital is exacerbated by institutional (credit, markets, inputs) and natural (drought, cyclones, and floods) causes.It is discussed how small, marginal, and large-scale farmers are doing.Following an explanation of the current situation, the authors make recommendations for potential government actions to address the crisis.These include the formation of farmer's groups, the adoption of non-pesticidal management practices to lower input costs, the correction of market anomalies, and the provision of counseling and measures to boost confidence in distressed areas known as "hot spots."[2] Dr. Tanaji K. Udgirkar (2013), he claimed that there are significant economic and social ramifications for farmers as a result of India's ongoing problem with rural indebtedness.The government has been working to lessen this burden, but each year it gets heavier.The essay investigates the relationship between rural debt and farmer suicides by analyzing data from the National Crime Record Bureau.According to the research, Maharashtra has a larger percentage of indebted farmers than any other state-48.80%amongall Indian farmers.The fact that non-institutional organizations continue to be important in rural loan markets in spite of institutional advancement highlights how difficult it will be to solve this persistent problem.[3] Rajwinder Kaur & Dr.Manisha Sharma (2012), they highlight in their research that progressive agriculture is a powerful engine of economic growth that promotes advancement in other fields.Following independence, the Indian government launched programs including new agricultural technology and provided financial assistance to farmers who were unable to purchase pricey inputs.Subsidies, however criticized for being expensive, have proved essential to sustaining farmer income and agricultural output.
According to the study, the expansion in gross cropped area during liberalization periods has not kept up with the overall subsidies (fertilizers, energy, and irrigation).This suggests that a sensible policy should give priority to small farmers who may not actually be recipients of subsidies.[4] Mukhopadhyay, B.R. (2020), he proposed that folk songs in rural India are essential for teaching farmers about proper hygiene measures.The Indian government offers financial assistance in the form of subsidies, crop damage compensation, direct crop purchasing, and health worker insurance, even though it can be difficult to maintain social distance when working on farms.The goal of programs like cash transfers and free grain distribution is to lessen rural hardship, particularly for laborers and tenant farmers.But maintaining the vital food supply chain during lockdowns presents difficulties that call for creative thinking and long-term planning in the agriculture industry.

Methodology
Our survey, conducted among 200 farmers in the surrounding areas of Kaithal, Haryana, owning 15-30 acres of land, revealed a comprehensive snapshot of the challenges faced by this agricultural community.Unpredicted weather conditions emerged as a pressing concern, with a significant number of farmers expressing difficulties navigating how frequent it would rain to acquire knowledge for managing the water supply for their crops.Financial issues were another prominent theme, reflecting the economic strain experienced by many in the farming community.A substantial portion of the respondents highlighted challenges related to debt and its high rate of interest, emphasizing the urgent need for financial support and sustainable debt management solutions.Moreover, farmers expressed concerns about the limited adoption of modern agricultural technologies, citing technological barriers that hindered their efficiency and productivity.Land ownership issues were also prevalent, with some farmers facing challenges related to land fragmentation and tenure security.These findings underscore the multifaceted nature of the obstacles faced by farmers in the region, highlighting the importance of targeted interventions and holistic support systems to address their diverse needs.

Results and Discussion
Out of the 200 farmers surveyed, 25% of them had taken loan from banks.The rest 75% procured funds through commission agents.The commission agents not only charge a high rate of interest (1.5% per month) but also increase the probability of exploitation on them for funds.Moreover this means that if a farmer takes a loan from the government of ₹10,00,000, they have to return 9% as tax (₹90,000).On the other hand if they take the same amount from the commission agent they have to return (₹1,80,000) which is twice the amount than what they would have paid to the banks.Therefore 20% of the farmers are unable to compete with the high rate of interest provided by their commission agents thus leading them to a debt trap.Though the process of obtaining funds through commission agents is easier and less complex, the farmers do not realize the tax benefits and subsidies they could obtain if they procure the funds from the government.Apart from the low rate of interest provided by the banks, they even give subsidies and reduce the principal amount.
Apart from the increased rate of interest, this year due to excess rain which resulted into water logging, almost 42% of the farmers had to incur loss.Regardless of the consistent rain this year, the groundwater has not been rising, instead in Sultanian, Cheeka the groundwater table has reached below 600 ft thus making it immensely difficult to access water in those regions.Around 25% of farmers are unable to sustain a living solely through farming practices thus may increase chances of not repaying their debt to their respective money lenders and getting confined into a debt trap.100farmers had small unowned land for cultivation, they also did not have finances to buy machinery for land use, neither did the farmers with large lands have the machinery for cultivation of crops, thus they were forced to use manual labors costing within the range of ₹450-650.Due to market fluctuations, they were forced to sell the produce at a lower price all the time, thus they always stayed in debt

Proposed solution for financial Issues:
Addressing the debt burden of farmers requires a multi-faceted approach involving government policies, financial institutions, and agricultural practices.Here are some potential solutions:

Loan Waivers and Debt Relief Programs:
Governments may consider implementing targeted loan waiver programs to alleviate the immediate debt burden on farmers.However, this should be accompanied by long-term solutions to prevent the recurrence of debt.

Financial Inclusion:
Improving access to formal financial institutions and promoting financial literacy among farmers can help them make informed decisions about borrowing and financial management.

Crop Insurance:
Implementing effective crop insurance schemes can protect farmers from the financial impact of crop failures due to natural disasters, pests, or diseases.

Diversification of Income Sources:
Encouraging farmers to diversify their sources of income beyond traditional crop farming, such as livestock farming, agro-processing, or agri-tourism, can provide additional revenue streams and reduce dependency on a single crop.

Price Stabilization Mechanisms:
Implementing policies that ensure fair and stable prices for agricultural produce can mitigate the income volatility faced by farmers.This may involve setting minimum support prices or establishing market intervention mechanisms.

Investment in Agricultural Infrastructure:
Improving agricultural infrastructure, including irrigation systems, storage facilities, and transportation networks, can help reduce post-harvest losses and increase the overall efficiency of the agricultural supply chain.

Extension Services and Technology Adoption:
Providing farmers with access to modern farming techniques, technology, and extension services can enhance productivity and reduce production costs, ultimately improving the financial viability of farming.

Land Reforms:
Addressing issues related to land fragmentation and ensuring secure land tenure can contribute to sustainable and efficient agricultural practices.

Capacity Building and Training:
Offering training programs to farmers on financial management, sustainable farming practices, and market trends can empower them to make informed decisions and manage their resources effectively.

Community-Based Initiatives:
Encouraging the formation of farmer cooperatives and self-help groups can enable collective bargaining power, bulk purchasing, and shared resources, leading to better economic outcomes for farmers.It's crucial to recognize that solutions must be context-specific, considering the unique challenges faced by farmers in different regions.A comprehensive and collaborative effort involving government bodies, financial institutions, non-governmental organizations, and the farming community is necessary to address the complex issue of the debt burden on farmers.

Proposed solution for small land holdings:
The problem of small landholding among Indian farmers is a complex issue with deep-rooted historical, social, and economic dimensions.However, several strategies and interventions can be considered to address this challenge:

Consolidation of Land Holdings:
Encourage voluntary land consolidation to create larger, more economically viable farms.Facilitate land pooling arrangements where small landholders can combine their plots into larger contiguous parcels.

Tenure Security:
Ensure secure land tenure to encourage long-term investments in the land.Implement and enforce land reform policies to address issues of land fragmentation and improve land records.

Promotion of Agroforestry and Horticulture:
Promote the cultivation of high-value crops, agroforestry, and horticulture, which can generate higher income per unit of land compared to traditional crops.

Cooperative Farming:
Encourage the formation of farmer cooperatives and producer groups to pool resources, share equipment, and collectively market their produce.
Cooperative farming can help smallholders achieve economies of scale and increase bargaining power.

Technology Adoption:
Promote the adoption of modern agricultural technologies and practices that enhance productivity, allowing farmers to make more efficient use of limited land.
Provide training and extension services to farmers on precision farming, organic farming, and sustainable practices.

Access to Credit and Inputs:
Ensure smallholders have access to affordable credit and inputs like seeds, fertilizers, and machinery.Implement government schemes that provide financial support, subsidies, and easy credit to small farmers.

Rural Infrastructure Development:
Invest in rural infrastructure, including irrigation facilities, roads, and transportation networks, to improve connectivity and reduce post-harvest losses.

Promotion of Livelihood Diversification:
Encourage small farmers to diversify their income sources by engaging in allied activities like animal husbandry, poultry, or non-farm enterprises.

Land Leasing Policies:
Implement and regulate land leasing policies to facilitate the leasing of agricultural land, allowing smallholders to expand their operations without the need for outright land ownership.

Government Support and Subsidies:
Provide targeted government support and subsidies to smallholders to enable them to adopt modern farming techniques, invest in technology, and improve productivity.

Skill Development and Education:
Invest in agricultural education and skill development programs to empower farmers with the knowledge and skills needed for sustainable and profitable farming.Addressing the issue of small landholding requires a holistic and integrated approach, involving collaboration between government agencies, non-governmental organizations, financial institutions, and the farming community.Policymakers should consider region-specific challenges and tailor interventions to the unique circumstances of different farming communities.

Proposed solution for water scarcity: Technical solution: Precision Irrigation:
Discuss the benefits of precision irrigation technologies in optimizing water use by delivering the right amount of water at the right time and location.Highlight successful case studies and the potential for widespread adoption.

[ 5 ]
Rakhra, M. et al (2022),According to their research, agricultural automation emphasizes the effective use of machinery while reducing the physical labor and debt incurred by farmers.The paper presents the novel idea of custom hiring centers with the goal of encouraging farmers to utilize technology for better resource management.He addressed the difficulties farmers encounter in obtaining tools and equipment in a pilot research involving 562 farmers in India, emphasizing their strong interest in rental and sharing possibilities.Decision trees were shown to be the most successful model by the research using machine learning techniques, illustrating possible social and economic effects on farmers' livelihoods.[6]