The Paradox of Participation: A Critical Synthesis of Community-Based Forest Governance through Van Panchayats in the Indian Himalayas

Pradnya Mohan Katke

doi:10.36948/ijfmr.2025.v07i04.54350

The Paradox of Participation: A Critical Synthesis of Community-Based Forest Governance through Van Panchayats in the Indian Himalayas

Author(s)	Ms. Pradnya Mohan Katke
Country	India
Abstract	Van Panchayats (VPs), or community forest councils, in the Indian Himalayan state of Uttarakhand represent one of Asia's oldest and most extensive experiments in decentralized forest governance. Originating from grassroots resistance to colonial forest policies in the early 20th century, these institutions were founded on the principle of community autonomy. This paper presents a critical synthesis of existing research to analyze the profound paradox that defines the contemporary state of Van Panchayats. Empirical evidence consistently demonstrates that VP-managed forests exhibit superior ecological outcomes—including better regeneration and higher biomass—at a lower cost compared to state-managed forests. However, these institutions are simultaneously in a state of crisis, their functional autonomy progressively eroded by a series of post-independence legislative amendments and increasing bureaucratic control. This analysis argues that the predicament of the Van Panchayat is not one of community failure but of institutional disempowerment. Through a detailed examination of their historical genesis, legislative evolution, and the complex on-ground dynamics of participation, gender inclusion, and elite capture, this paper reveals a system where a resilient and effective grassroots model is being systematically weakened by the state it is intended to partner with. The findings indicate a vicious cycle where diminished autonomy demotivates meaningful community participation, which in turn legitimizes further state intervention. We conclude with a set of integrated policy imperatives aimed at revitalizing these crucial institutions by restoring their autonomy, deepening social inclusion, and harmonizing their role within India's broader forest governance landscape.
Keywords	Van Panchayat, community-based forest management, participatory governance, decentralization, bureaucratic control, elite capture, gender equity, forest policy, Indian Himalayas, Uttarakhand
Field	Biology > Agriculture / Botany
Published In	Volume 7, Issue 4, July-August 2025
Published On	2025-08-31
DOI	https://doi.org/10.36948/ijfmr.2025.v07i04.54350

View / Download PDF File

E-ISSN 2582-2160

doi

CrossRef DOI is assigned to each research paper published in our journal.

IJFMR DOI prefix is
10.36948/ijfmr

Downloads

Research Paper Format Copyright Permission Form and Undertaking Form Cover Page Vol 8 Isu 2 Cover Page Vol 8 Isu 1 Cover Page Vol 7 Isu 6

All research papers published on this website are licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, and all rights belong to their respective authors/researchers.

CC-BY-SA

About IJFMR Fees & Payment Current Issue Publication Archive	Submit Research Paper Track Submission Status Publication Guidelines Publication Ethics Peer Review & Plagiarism	Join as a Reviewer Editors & Reviewers Reviewer Referral Program Get Reviewer Membership Certi.	Website/Journal Policies Usage Policy Content Policies Privacy Policy

Contact Us		+91-9687-828-838	editor@ijfmr.com

International Journal For Multidisciplinary Research

A Widely Indexed Open Access Peer Reviewed Multidisciplinary Bi-monthly Scholarly International Journal

The Paradox of Participation: A Critical Synthesis of Community-Based Forest Governance through Van Panchayats in the Indian Himalayas

Share this